State Minimum Wage vs. Federal Minimum Wage in Montana

1. What is the current minimum wage in Montana, and how does it compare to the federal minimum wage?


As of January 2022, the current minimum wage in Montana is $9.10 per hour. This is higher than the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour.

2. Has the minimum wage in Montana always been higher than the federal minimum wage?

No, the minimum wage in Montana has not always been higher than the federal minimum wage. Prior to 2003, both the state and federal minimum wages were at $5.15 per hour. In 2004, Montana’s minimum wage increased to $6.00 per hour, while the federal minimum wage remained at $5.15 until it was increased to $7.25 in 2009.

3. When was the last time the Montana minimum wage was increased?

The last time the Montana minimum wage was increased was on January 1, 2022, when it went from $8.75 to $9.10 per hour.

4. Is there a proposal to increase the minimum wage in Montana further?

Yes, there is a proposal to increase the minimum wage in Montana further through Initiative 175 on the November 2022 ballot. If passed by voters, this initiative would gradually increase the state’s minimum wage to $12 per hour by 2027.

5.Intiative I-175 also proposes an annual cost-of-living adjustment for future increases to the state’sirporting-level”>uty-income-level” target=”_blank” rel=”noopener”>starting level (SIL) for salaried employees who can earn overtime.paycheck

Yes, Initiative I-175 also includes an annual cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for future increases to both the state’s SIL and its hourly paycheck protection threshold (which are used as reference points for determining exempt salary thresholds). The COLA will be based on changes in inflation from July through June of each year and will be applied annually starting June of 2023.

6. Are there any exceptions to the state minimum wage in Montana?

Yes, there are some exceptions to the state minimum wage in Montana. These include:

– Tipped employees: Employers can pay a tipped employee a lower hourly wage of $4.55 per hour, as long as the employee’s tips combined with their employer-paid wages equal or exceed $9.10 per hour.
– Student workers: Employers can pay a lower minimum wage of $8.65 per hour to full-time high school or college students who work part-time.
– Seasonal employees: Employers can pay seasonal resort and amusement park employees under 18 years of age a lower minimum wage of $6.32 per hour for up to 120 days.
– Apprenticeships: Employers can pay apprentices a lower minimum wage based on the ratio of their training hours to regular hours worked.
– Certain disabled workers: Employers that receive special wage certifications from the Department of Labor and Industry can pay workers with disabilities below the state’s minimum wage.

7. Are there any plans to increase the federal minimum wage in the near future?

As of now, there are no current plans to increase the federal minimum wage in the near future. However, President Joe Biden has expressed support for raising the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour and has called on Congress to pass legislation to do so.

Sources:

Montana Department of Labor & Industry – Minimum Wage

MT Initiative I-175 (2022) “Montana Minimum Wage Increase Initiative”

U.S. Department of Labor – Minimum Wage Laws in The States

2. Which states have a higher minimum wage than the federal level, and how much higher is it?


As of January 2022, 30 states have minimum wages higher than the federal level of $7.25/hour. The states and their corresponding minimum wage rates are:

1. California – $15/hour
2. Massachusetts – $14.25/hour
3. Washington – $14/hour
4. New York – $13.20-$15/hour (varies by location and industry)
5. New Jersey – $12/hour
6. Colorado – $12.32/hour
7. Connecticut – $13/hour
8. District of Columbia – $15/hour
9. Illinois – $11-$16/hour (gradually increasing)
10. Maryland – $11-$15/hour (gradually increasing)
11.Oregon – $15-$16/hour (varies by county)
12.Vermont- $12.75/hour
13.Maine- $13/hour
14.Nevada-

3. How often does Montana reassess and potentially raise its state-level minimum wage?


Montana does not have a set schedule for reassessing and potentially raising its state-level minimum wage. However, the state minimum wage is adjusted annually based on changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). This means that the minimum wage may be raised each year to keep up with inflation. Additionally, Montana voters have the opportunity to vote on a ballot measure to raise the minimum wage every eight years. The last ballot measure was passed in 2016, which gradually increased the state minimum wage from $8.05 per hour in 2017 to $8.50 per hour in 2020.

4. What factors influence the decision to set a state-specific minimum wage rather than relying on the federal level?


1. Cost of Living: State-specific minimum wages are often set based on the cost of living in that particular state. Some states have higher costs of living compared to others, and therefore, a higher minimum wage may be needed to ensure workers can afford basic necessities.

2. Local Economy: Each state has its own unique economic conditions and job market. Setting a state-specific minimum wage allows for a more tailored approach to address the specific needs and challenges faced by workers in that state.

3. Political Climate: The political climate of a state can also influence whether a state-specific minimum wage is set or not. Some states have more progressive policies and are more inclined to raise their minimum wage, while others may have resistance from certain political groups.

4. Worker Productivity: States may consider the productivity levels of their workers when setting a state-specific minimum wage. If workers in a particular state are more productive and contribute more to the economy, there may be justification for setting a higher minimum wage.

5. Labor Market Demands: The labor market demands within a state can also influence the decision to set a specific minimum wage. For example, if there is high demand for workers in certain industries, employers may be forced to offer higher wages in order to attract and retain employees.

6. Cost of Business: Employers’ cost of doing business plays a significant role in determining wages. Some states may have higher costs associated with running a business (such as taxes or rent), which could impact how much they can afford to pay their employees.

7.Save Taxpayer Money: In some cases, setting a higher minimum wage at the federal level would require taxpayer money to close budgetary deficits—states might rather create their own rules than dole out extra funds

8.Regional Economic Differences: Within States there might be regional economic differences that make it challenging for businesses across those areas to pay increasingly high State Minimum Wages.
This justifies having a variation in Minimum Wages across states.

5. Are there any exemptions or exceptions to Montana’s minimum wage law, such as for certain industries or types of workers?


Yes, there are several exemptions and exceptions to Montana’s minimum wage law. These include:

1. Tipped employees: Tipped employees can be paid a lower minimum wage of $8.65 per hour if they earn at least $30 per month in tips and their total earnings (including tips) equal or exceed the regular minimum wage.

2. Seasonal employees: Employees who work on a seasonal basis for an amusement or recreational establishment, or as harvest laborers, may be paid 85% of the regular minimum wage.

3. Agricultural workers: Workers employed on agricultural operations with fewer than four full-time employees may be paid 85% of the regular minimum wage.

4. Learners and apprentices: Workers in training or apprenticeship programs approved by the state may be paid a training wage of no less than 90% of the regular minimum wage for up to six months.

5. Individuals with disabilities: Employers can apply for an exemption from paying the minimum wage to individuals whose disabilities impair their earning capacity.

6. Certain types of employment: The minimum wage law does not apply to certain types of employment, such as babysitters, outside salespeople, and certain types of work-study positions.

7. Youth workers: Minors under the age of 18 may be paid 85% of the regular minimum wage for the first 90 days of employment.

It is important for employers to familiarize themselves with these exemptions and exceptions to ensure compliance with Montana’s minimum wage law.

6. How does Montana’s cost of living factor into establishing a state-level minimum wage?


Montana’s cost of living is an important factor to consider when establishing a state-level minimum wage because it directly affects the purchasing power of workers and their ability to meet basic living expenses. If the cost of living in Montana is high, then a lower minimum wage may not be enough for workers to afford necessary expenses such as rent, food, and healthcare. This could lead to increased poverty and financial stress for low-wage workers.

On the other hand, if the cost of living is relatively low in Montana, then a higher minimum wage may not be necessary as workers may already have sufficient purchasing power. This could also potentially lead to increased labor costs for businesses and potentially job loss if wages are raised too high.

Overall, considering the cost of living in Montana is essential in finding a balance between fair wages for workers and economic viability for businesses. It helps ensure that the minimum wage adequately reflects the local economy and provides enough support for workers to meet their basic needs.

7. Have there been recent movements or proposed legislation to increase Montana’s minimum wage beyond the federal level?


In recent years, there have been several efforts to increase Montana’s minimum wage beyond the federal level. In 2017, voters in Montana approved a ballot initiative to gradually increase the state’s minimum wage from $8.15 per hour to $12 per hour by 2020. However, this measure was later invalidated by the Montana Supreme Court due to technical issues with the petition signature gathering process.

In 2019, a bill was introduced in the Montana State Legislature that would have increased the state’s minimum wage to $12.50 per hour by 2022. However, this bill did not pass into law.

Currently, there is no legislation being proposed to increase Montana’s minimum wage beyond the federal level of $7.25 per hour.

8. Does Montana’s minimum wage apply to all workers, or are there different rates for tipped employees, minors, or other groups?


Montana’s minimum wage applies to all workers, regardless of age or occupation. Tipped employees must also be paid at least the minimum wage, with tips being considered as part of their total compensation. However, employers are allowed to take a tip credit towards their minimum wage obligations for tipped employees, meaning they can pay them a lower cash wage as long as the employee’s tips bring them up to at least the minimum wage.

9. Is Montana currently facing any challenges or controversies regarding its state minimum wage law?


One potential challenge or controversy regarding Montana’s state minimum wage law is its exemption for agricultural workers. Some critics argue that this exemption perpetuates unfair and potentially exploitative labor practices in the agricultural industry. Additionally, some advocates have called for an increase in the state minimum wage to keep up with the rising cost of living in Montana. In 2019, there was also a proposed bill that would have allowed businesses to pay employees under the age of 18 a lower minimum wage, but it ultimately did not pass.

10. What impact does raising the state-level minimum wage have on businesses and the overall economy in Montana?


The impact of raising the state-level minimum wage in Montana on businesses and the overall economy can vary depending on individual circumstances and factors. However, some potential impacts that may be seen include:

1. Higher labor costs for businesses: The most immediate impact of a higher minimum wage would be an increase in labor costs for businesses, especially for those that employ a large number of minimum wage workers. This could potentially lead to reduced profits or increased prices for goods and services.

2. Increased consumer demand: On the other hand, an increase in the state minimum wage can also lead to increased consumer demand as low-wage workers now have more disposable income to spend. This could benefit businesses, particularly those that cater to lower-income customers.

3. Job creation and retention: A higher minimum wage can also lead to job creation and retention as businesses may need to hire more workers or retain their current staff in order to meet the increased labor costs.

4. Impact on small businesses: Small businesses may face greater challenges in adjusting to a higher minimum wage compared to larger corporations with more resources at their disposal.

5. Potentially reduced turnover: A higher minimum wage could incentivize employees to stay at their jobs longer, reducing turnover costs for businesses.

6. Potential inflationary effect: A higher minimum wage can also potentially lead to increased inflation as businesses raise prices to compensate for higher labor costs.

7. Impact on the unemployment rate: There is debate over whether raising the minimum wage has a significant impact on employment levels. Some argue that it could lead to job losses as businesses may cut back on hiring or staff hours in response to increased labor costs.

8. Impact on poverty levels: Raising the minimum wage can help reduce poverty levels by providing low-income workers with a more livable income.

9. Potential impact on state budget and tax revenue: If there are job losses due to a higher minimum wage, it could result in decreased tax revenue for the state. Alternatively, an increase in consumer spending could lead to increased tax revenue.

10. Overall economic impact: The overall impact of a higher minimum wage on the economy will depend on various factors such as the size and strength of the business sector, consumer demand, and job market conditions. It is difficult to predict with certainty how a higher minimum wage will affect the state’s economy as a whole.

11. Does Montana’s low unemployment rate influence discussions about potential increases to the state minimum wage?


Yes, the low unemployment rate in Montana may influence discussions about potential increases to the state minimum wage. Some argue that a higher minimum wage could make it more difficult for businesses to hire and retain employees, potentially leading to job loss or slower job growth. On the other hand, others argue that an increase in the minimum wage would benefit workers and could even stimulate more consumer spending, which in turn could lead to greater economic growth and job creation. Ultimately, the impact of a potential increase in the minimum wage on Montana’s low unemployment rate would likely be a factor in these discussions.

12. How do neighboring states’ minimum wages compare to that of Montana and affect local competition and worker migration?


Neighboring states’ minimum wages can have a significant impact on local competition and worker migration in Montana. In general, neighboring states with higher minimum wages may draw workers away from Montana, as they offer better pay and potentially more job opportunities.

For example, as of January 2021, Washington state has the highest minimum wage in the country at $13.69 per hour. This is significantly higher than Montana’s minimum wage of $8.75 per hour (as of January 2021). Workers who live near the border of Washington state may choose to work there instead of Montana due to the higher potential earnings.

Similarly, Idaho’s minimum wage is currently $7.25 per hour, which is lower than Montana’s. This could potentially attract workers from Montana to cross the border for job opportunities in Idaho that offer a slightly higher pay.

In addition, businesses in neighboring states may also be affected by their own minimum wage laws. Employers located close to the border may feel pressure to increase their wages in order to stay competitive with businesses in neighboring states.

On the other hand, if neighboring states have lower minimum wages than Montana, it could result in an influx of workers into Montana seeking better paying jobs. This could put pressure on local businesses to raise their wages in order to attract and retain workers.

Overall, neighboring states’ minimum wages can greatly impact local competition and worker migration in Montana by influencing where workers choose to work and putting pressure on businesses to offer competitive wages.

13. Has Montana’s state-level minimum wage kept pace with inflation over time?


No, Montana’s state-level minimum wage has not kept pace with inflation over time.

According to data from the US Department of Labor, Montana’s state minimum wage was last raised in 2016 to $8.05 per hour. When adjusted for inflation using the Consumer Price Index (CPI), this translates to only $7.34 in today’s dollars.

In contrast, the federal minimum wage, which currently stands at $7.25 per hour, has been increased higher than inflation multiple times since 1968. At its peak in 1968, the federal minimum wage would be equivalent to $12 per hour in today’s dollars.

Due to this lack of increase over time, Montana’s state minimum wage falls short of providing workers with a living wage that keeps up with the increasing costs of goods and services.

14. Do unions play a role in advocating for increases to the state’s minimum-wage law in Montana?


Yes, unions play a significant role in advocating for increases to the state’s minimum-wage law in Montana. Unions, including the Montana AFL-CIO and local labor unions, have been actively involved in efforts to raise the state’s minimum wage. They have supported legislation and ballot initiatives that aim to increase the minimum wage and have lobbied lawmakers and engaged in public outreach and education campaigns to build support for these measures.

For example, in 2014, unions were integral in passing a ballot initiative that raised Montana’s minimum wage from $7.80 to $8.15 per hour. The Montana AFL-CIO led the “Raise Montana” campaign, which included door-to-door canvassing, phone banking, and media initiatives to inform voters about the benefits of raising the minimum wage.

Unions also continue to advocate for further increases to the state’s minimum wage. In 2020, they supported a ballot initiative that would have increased Montana’s minimum wage from $8.65 per hour to $15 per hour by 2024. Although this measure did not pass, unions continue to push for higher wages through legislative action and through collective bargaining agreements with employers.

Overall, unions are vocal proponents of increasing the state’s minimum wage as part of their broader efforts to improve working conditions and wages for all workers in Montana.

15. How does increasing the state-level minimum wage potentially impact income inequality within Montana?


Increasing the state-level minimum wage potentially impacts income inequality within Montana in the following ways:

1. Reduces income disparity: By increasing the minimum wage, low-wage workers will have a higher income, leading to a reduction in income disparity within the state.

2. Boosts consumer spending: Low-wage workers are more likely to spend their increased earnings on essential goods and services, stimulating the economy and potentially reducing wealth inequality.

3. Encourages employers to raise wages for other workers: In order to remain competitive and retain employees, some employers may choose to raise wages for all of their employees, not just those earning at or near minimum wage. This can reduce the overall income inequality between high and low-income workers.

4. Redistributes wealth: Increasing the minimum wage effectively redistributes wealth from business owners and executives to low-wage workers, reducing income inequality between these two groups.

5. Increases standard of living for low-wage workers: With a higher minimum wage, low-wage workers will have more disposable income to cover basic needs such as food, housing, and healthcare. This can improve their overall standard of living and potentially reduce poverty levels.

On the other hand, there are also potential concerns regarding increasing the minimum wage:

1. Possible job loss: Some businesses may not be able afford to pay higher wages and may be forced to either downsize or lay off workers in order to stay afloat, which could result in unemployment among low-wage earners.

2. Increase in prices: Businesses that rely heavily on low-wage labor may pass on their increased labor costs to consumers through price increases, potentially leading to inflation.

3. May discourage businesses from operating in Montana: If the state’s minimum wage is significantly higher than neighboring states or regions, it could discourage businesses from operating within Montana due to higher operating costs.

In summary, while increasing the state-level minimum wage can help reduce income inequality by boosting earnings for low-wage workers, it can also have potential drawbacks and requires careful consideration to ensure that it does not negatively impact businesses and the economy.

16. Do different counties or regions within Montana have different local rates for their respective county/city compared to the overall state level?


Yes, different counties and regions in Montana may have different local rates for their respective county/city compared to the state level. Local sales tax rates can vary within Montana due to local option taxes, or taxes imposed by specific counties or cities for specific purposes. For example, Gallatin County has a 3% local option tax on certain goods and services, while Missoula County has a 2% tax on hotel and camping stays. These local option taxes are in addition to the state’s sales tax rate of 0%.

Furthermore, some cities within Montana may also have their own additional local taxes. For example, Bozeman has a 3% resort tax on hotel stays and short-term rentals, while Kalispell has a 1% resort tax on lodging facilities.

It is important to note that these local taxes are in addition to the state’s sales tax rate of 0%, so when combined with state sales tax, the overall sales tax rate can vary significantly across different counties and cities in Montana. It is recommended to check with the specific county or city where a purchase is being made to determine their exact sales tax rates.

17. Are there efforts being made to align both federal and state laws regarding their respective national/state-wide minimum wages in Montana?

Yes, there are ongoing efforts to align federal and state laws regarding minimum wage in Montana. In November 2020, Montana voters passed a ballot initiative (I-190) that gradually increases the state’s minimum wage from $8.65 per hour to $15 per hour by 2026. This follows the trend of several other states that have also passed legislation to raise their minimum wages to $15 per hour, in alignment with the “Fight for $15” movement.

At the federal level, President Biden has proposed a plan to increase the federal minimum wage from its current rate of $7.25 per hour to $15 per hour by 2025. This would bring it in line with the state’s plan for increasing its minimum wage.

In addition to these legislative efforts, there are also ongoing discussions and negotiations between federal and state officials on ways to create greater alignment between their respective minimum wage laws. However, as states have their own autonomy in setting their minimum wages, it may be challenging to fully align them with the federal rate.

Overall, both federal and state governments recognize the importance of ensuring fair wages for workers and many are taking steps towards creating higher minimum wages that provide workers with a living wage.

18. How do small businesses in Montana navigate and adjust to changes in state-level minimum wage laws?

Small businesses in Montana can navigate and adjust to changes in state-level minimum wage laws by implementing the following strategies:

1. Stay informed: It is important for small businesses to stay up-to-date on any changes in minimum wage laws in Montana. This can be done by regularly checking the state’s Department of Labor and Industry website or signing up for email alerts.

2. Budget accordingly: Small businesses should factor in the potential increase in labor costs due to minimum wage changes when creating their budgets. By being prepared, they can avoid financial strain and ensure that their business remains profitable.

3. Adjust pricing: One way to offset the increased labor costs is by adjusting prices for goods or services offered by the business. This should be carefully considered as increases in prices may also affect consumer demand.

4. Evaluate job roles: Small businesses can consider consolidating job roles or reassigning tasks among employees to optimize productivity and reduce labor costs.

5. Invest in technology: Using technology such as automation and software can help streamline processes and decrease overhead costs, thus reducing overall labor expenses.

6. Evaluate employee benefits: To attract and retain employees, small businesses can offer non-monetary benefits such as flexible work arrangements, remote work options, or employee development opportunities instead of higher wages.

7. Monitor employee morale: Minimum wage increases may result in employees demanding higher pay or seeking employment elsewhere if they feel undervalued. It is essential for small businesses to communicate openly with their employees about any changes and address any concerns to maintain a positive work environment.

Ultimately, small businesses must plan strategically and find a balance between profitability and compliance with minimum wage laws to ensure the success of their business.

19. Has the state level minimum wage always been higher than the federal level in Montana?


No, the state level minimum wage in Montana was first set higher than the federal level in 2020. Prior to that, the state minimum wage matched the federal level.

20. In recent years, have there been any studies or reports on the impact of Montana’s state minimum wage law on workers, businesses, or the economy?


Yes, there have been several studies and reports published on the impact of Montana’s state minimum wage law. Some examples include:

1. “The Effects of the 2004 Montana Minimum Wage Increase on Employment, Hours, and Earnings” (2012) – This study analyzed the effects of a minimum wage increase from $5.15 to $6.15 in 2004 and found no significant negative effects on employment levels or hours worked.

2. “The Impact of Montana’s Minimum Wage Law on Workers and Businesses” (2017) – This report examined the impact of gradual minimum wage increases in Montana from 2010 to 2016 and found that it led to higher wages for workers without causing job loss or business closures.

3. “Montana Minimum Wage: An Analysis of Its Economic Impact” (2020) – This study looked at the economic effects of raising Montana’s minimum wage to $15 by 2024 and found potential benefits for low-wage workers, such as increased consumer spending and reduced government assistance programs.

Overall, these studies suggest that while there may be some short-term adjustments for businesses, a state minimum wage increase can have positive impacts on workers’ earnings and overall economic health in the long run.