Impact of State Policies on School Safety for Immigrant Students in New York

1. How are state policies addressing the safety of immigrant students in New York?


New York has several policies in place to address the safety of immigrant students, particularly those who may be at risk due to their immigration status. Some of these policies include:

1. Sanctuary Cities: Several cities in New York, including New York City and Albany, have declared themselves as “sanctuary cities” for immigrants. This means that local law enforcement will not cooperate with federal immigration authorities in identifying or deporting undocumented immigrants, unless they have a criminal record.

2. Executive Order on Protecting Immigrant Students: In 2017, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo signed an Executive Order that prohibits requests by public schools and colleges for information about students’ immigration status or that of their family members.

3. DREAM Act: In 2019, New York passed the DREAM Act which allows undocumented students to access state financial aid for higher education.

4. Education Department Guidance Letter: In 2018, the New York State Department of Education issued a guidance letter stating that all K-12 students have the right to enroll in school regardless of their immigration status and without being required to provide documentation.

5. Safe Spaces program: The New York City Department of Education has implemented a Safe Spaces program which provides training and support for schools to create a welcoming and safe environment for immigrant students and families.

6. Language Access Services: Under federal and state laws, all public schools are required to provide language access services such as interpretation and translation services for limited English proficient families.

7. Office of Immigration Affairs: The New York City Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs provides resources and support for immigrant communities, including legal assistance, financial counseling, and anti-bullying programs.

Overall, these policies aim to protect the rights of immigrant students and ensure they have access to education without discrimination based on their immigration status.

2. Have there been any specific measures taken by New York to ensure the safety of immigrant students in schools?


Yes, New York has taken specific measures to ensure the safety of immigrant students in schools, including:

1. The New York State Dignity for All Students Act (DASA): This law includes provisions to protect immigrant students from discrimination and harassment based on their immigration status.

2. The Welcoming Schools Initiative: This initiative provides resources and support for educators to create a welcoming and inclusive environment for all students, including immigrants.

3. Language Access: New York City schools provide translation and interpretation services for families who speak languages other than English, ensuring that immigrant parents can communicate with school staff about their child’s education.

4. “Sanctuary” Policies: Several cities in New York, including New York City, have adopted “sanctuary” policies that limit cooperation between local law enforcement agencies and federal immigration authorities in order to protect undocumented immigrants from deportation.

5. Safe Zones: In 2017, the New York State Education Department launched a Safe Zone initiative which designates schools as safe places where immigration enforcement actions are not allowed without a judicial warrant or court order.

6. Counseling and Support Services: Many schools have dedicated counselors and support staff specifically to address the needs of immigrant students, providing emotional support and connecting them with necessary resources.

7. Know Your Rights Workshops: Schools in districts with large immigrant populations often hold workshops or information sessions to educate students on their rights as immigrants and what to do if they are confronted by immigration officials.

3. What effect have government policies had on the well-being and safety of immigrant students in schools in New York?


There are a number of government policies that have affected the well-being and safety of immigrant students in schools in New York. Some of these include:

1. Immigration Policies: The current immigration policies put in place by the federal government have a direct impact on the well-being and safety of immigrant students in schools. The fear and uncertainty caused by the threat of deportation or detention can have a significant impact on the mental health and academic performance of these students.

2. Language Access Policies: In 2015, New York City passed Executive Order No. 120, which requires all city agencies to provide interpretation and translation services to individuals with limited English proficiency. This has helped to increase access to education for immigrant students who may struggle with English as a second language.

3. School Safety Policies: In recent years, there has been increased attention towards school safety policies, particularly in response to mass shootings. However, some of these policies, such as metal detectors and random searches, have disproportionately targeted students of color, including many immigrant students.

4. Special Education Services: Many immigrant students with disabilities face challenges accessing necessary special education services due to lack of awareness or language barriers. This can significantly impact their educational success and mental health.

Overall, government policies play a crucial role in shaping the experiences and opportunities available to immigrant students in schools in New York. They can either promote inclusivity and support for these vulnerable individuals or perpetuate systemic barriers and discrimination that negatively affect their well-being and safety.

4. Are there any programs or initiatives in place to support the mental health and well-being of immigrant students in New York schools?


Yes, there are several programs and initiatives in place to support the mental health and well-being of immigrant students in New York schools. These include:

1. Culturally Responsive-Sustaining Education Framework: This framework, implemented by the New York State Education Department, emphasizes the importance of creating a culturally responsive and inclusive learning environment for all students, particularly those from immigrant backgrounds.

2. Multilingual Learner Supports: The New York City Department of Education provides a range of supports for multilingual learners (MLLs) including translation services, bilingual education programs, and English as a Second Language instruction to help them succeed academically and socio-emotionally.

3. Mental Health First Aid Training: The NYC Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs offers Mental Health First Aid training to educators and school staff to help identify and address mental health issues among immigrant students.

4. Community Schools Initiative: This initiative focuses on providing comprehensive supports to students and families in high-needs communities, including mental health services.

5. School-Based Mental Health Clinics: Many schools in New York have on-site mental health clinics staffed by licensed therapists who provide individual and group counseling services to students.

6. Culturally Competent Counseling Services: Several organizations like the Association for Mental Health and Wellness provide culturally competent counseling services specifically designed for immigrant students and families.

7. Immigrant-focused Support Groups: Some schools also have support groups for immigrant students where they can connect with peers who share similar experiences.

8. Professional Development for Educators: Various organizations offer professional development programs that equip educators with the knowledge and skills needed to effectively support immigrant students’ mental health needs.

5. How has the current political climate and immigration policies impacted the safety of immigrant students in schools in New York?


The current political climate and immigration policies have created a sense of fear and uncertainty among immigrant students in schools in New York. The increased rhetoric and actions targeting immigrants has made many students anxious about their safety, leading to a negative impact on their mental well-being.

One of the main ways this has affected immigrant students is through the increase in ICE raids and deportations. These actions have led to the separation of families, causing emotional distress for children who may have parents or other family members at risk of being deported. The fear of deportation can also lead to absenteeism among immigrant students, as they may be afraid to leave their homes or attend school activities.

Furthermore, there has been an increase in bullying and discrimination against immigrant students. With the rise in xenophobia and anti-immigrant sentiments, some students have become targets for verbal and physical harassment. This not only affects their sense of safety but also creates barriers for them to fully participate in school activities.

In addition, the Trump administration’s decision to rescind DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) has caused significant stress for undocumented students who were previously protected under this program. These students now face an uncertain future and fear that they may get deported if their DACA status expires before a potential pathway to citizenship is established.

Overall, the current political climate and immigration policies have significantly impacted the safety of immigrant students in schools in New York. It is important for schools to address these concerns and provide support systems for immigrant students to ensure their well-being and academic success.

6. Are there any collaborations between schools, law enforcement, and community organizations to address school safety for immigrant students in New York?


Yes, there are several collaborations and initiatives in place to address the safety of immigrant students in New York schools. These include:

1. New York State Education Department (NYSED) Collaborative: NYSED has collaborated with various organizations, including the New York Immigration Coalition and the New York State Office of Victim Services, to create a statewide framework for supporting immigrant students and their families.

2. NYS Office for New Americans Community Schools Initiative: This initiative brings together schools, community-based organizations, and local government agencies to provide academic and social support services to immigrant students in underserved areas.

3. NYPD School Safety Division’s Multilingual Unit: This unit serves as a liaison between schools, law enforcement, and immigrant communities by providing translation services and building relationships with immigrant families.

4. Sanctuary Schools Movement: A collaboration between educators, immigration advocates, and community organizers working to create safe and inclusive learning environments for all students regardless of immigration status.

5. Safe Passage Project: A partnership between The Legal Aid Society and volunteers from leading law firms that provide free legal representation to unaccompanied minors facing deportation.

6. My Brother’s Keeper NYC (MBK NYC): A citywide initiative that works with community-based organizations to provide programs and support services specifically for immigrant youth.

7. Organization of Hispanic Foundation & Library Association Initiative: Designed to help public libraries better serve the needs of Latino immigrants by providing resources on immigration issues and cultural competency training for library staff.

8.Major Cities Chiefs Police Association’s Statement on Immigration Enforcement in Schools: A cooperative effort among police chiefs across the country addressing key issues around school safety and immigration enforcement policies at the local level.

7. Do school districts in New York have specific protocols for handling safety concerns related to anti-immigrant sentiments or hate crimes targeting immigrant students?


Yes, school districts in New York are required to have specific protocols for handling safety concerns related to anti-immigrant sentiments or hate crimes targeting immigrant students. According to the New York State Education Department’s Dignity for All Students Act (DASA), all public schools in New York are required to adopt a Code of Conduct that includes specific provisions addressing harassment and discrimination based on a student’s race, color, national origin, ancestry, ethnic group identification, religion, religious practice, disability, weight, gender identity or expression, and sexual orientation. This includes protections against bias-based bullying and harassment directed at immigrant students.

Additionally, the New York State Education Department provides resources and guidance for schools on how to create a safe and inclusive learning environment for immigrant students. This includes providing information on federal laws protecting the rights of immigrant students and guidance on how to support the emotional well-being of immigrant students who may be experiencing stress or trauma due to anti-immigrant sentiment.

School districts also have established protocols for responding to incidents of hate speech or bias-based incidents targeting immigrant students. This may include reporting procedures for students and staff to report such incidents, conducting investigations into reported incidents, providing support services for affected students, and implementing disciplinary actions as necessary.

Furthermore, some school districts in New York have established policies specifically addressing immigration status or protecting the rights of undocumented students. For example, the New York City Department of Education has enacted a policy that prohibits schools from asking about a student’s immigration status and restricts federal immigration authorities from entering schools without a warrant.

Overall, school districts in New York are committed to promoting diversity and inclusion within their communities and have systems in place to address safety concerns related to anti-immigrant sentiments or hate crimes targeting immigrant students.

8. What steps does New York take to ensure that all schools, including those with high populations of immigrant students, have adequate security measures in place?


1. School Safety Teams: Each school in New York is required to have a designated safety team made up of parents, staff, and community members. These teams review the school’s safety plan and make recommendations for improving security measures.

2. Metal Detectors: Some schools in New York have metal detectors at their entrances to ensure that no weapons are brought into the building. These metal detectors are often used in schools with high populations of immigrant students.

3. Safety Assessments: Schools in New York City undergo regular safety assessments conducted by an independent team of experts trained by the NYPD. This assessment includes evaluating building security, emergency preparedness, and crisis response protocols.

4. School Resource Officers (SROs): Many schools in New York have SROs assigned to them, who are active-duty police officers that work directly with students and staff to promote safety and prevent crime.

5. Training for Staff: All school staff in New York receive training on emergency preparedness, threat assessment, conflict resolution, and other essential skills to prevent harmful situations from escalating.

6. Security Cameras: Many schools in New York have security cameras installed throughout the building as a deterrent to potential criminals and also aid in identifying perpetrators if an incident occurs.

7. Parent Communication Network: Parents of students enrolled in NYC public schools can sign up for Notify NYC emergency alerts to stay informed about school emergencies and closures.

8. Partnerships with Community Organizations: The New York City Department of Education works closely with community organizations such as immigrant advocacy groups and non-profits to provide resources and support for immigrant students’ families and address any concerns they may have about school safety.

9. Multi-Lingual Resources: To ensure that all families have access to information about school safety measures, the DOE provides translated materials and interpretation services for non-English speaking families.

10. Crisis Response Plans: All schools in New York must have a comprehensive crisis response plan that outlines protocols for various emergencies, including active shooter situations, natural disasters, and other potential threats. These plans are updated regularly and practiced through emergency drills.

11. Mental Health Support: The DOE offers mental health support services for students who may have experienced trauma or have ongoing safety concerns. Schools with high immigrant populations may also have specialized support programs to address the unique challenges these students may face.

12. Safe Passage Program: The Safe Passage program provides trained school staff members to safely escort students to and from school in high-risk neighborhoods. This service is particularly beneficial for immigrant students who may feel unsafe walking alone in an unfamiliar area.

9. Has there been an increase or decrease in incidents of bullying or discrimination against immigrant students since certain policies were implemented in New York schools?

10. How have schools with a high percentage of immigrant students addressed language barriers and provided adequate support for non-English speaking students?

10. Are there any challenges faced by educators when implementing state policies related to school safety for immigrant students in New York?


1. Language barriers: Many immigrant students may not speak English fluently, making it difficult for them to understand specific safety policies or communicate any concerns they may have.

2. Lack of cultural sensitivity: State policies related to school safety may not take into account the cultural backgrounds and experiences of immigrant students, leading to a lack of understanding and connection.

3. Fear of deportation: Immigrant students, especially those who are undocumented or have family members who are undocumented, may fear that implementing certain safety measures could result in their deportation or separation from their families.

4. Lack of resources: Some schools with high populations of immigrant students may not have the resources or funding to implement state-mandated safety policies effectively.

5. Inadequate training: Educators may not receive sufficient training on how to address the unique needs of immigrant students when implementing state policies related to school safety.

6. Resistance from certain groups: In some communities, there may be resistance or pushback against state policies related to school safety for immigrant students, making it challenging for educators to enforce these policies.

7. Trauma and past experiences: Immigrant students may have experienced trauma in their home countries or during their journey to the United States, making it more challenging for them to trust authority figures and follow safety protocols.

8. Resistance from parents/guardians: Some parents or guardians of immigrant students may be hesitant about providing personal information or allowing their children to participate in certain safety measures due to fear or mistrust of government agencies.

9. Insufficient communication with families: Communication between schools and immigrant families can be hindered by language barriers and cultural differences, making it difficult for educators to ensure the involvement and support of families in implementing state-mandated safety measures.

10. Limited access to mental health services: Immigrant students may face higher levels of stress and anxiety due to their immigration status, which could impact their well-being and ability to fully engage in school. However, limited access to mental health services can make it challenging for educators to provide necessary support and resources for these students.

11. What resources are available to support English language learning and integration for newly arrived immigrant students in schools throughout New York?


1. English as a Second Language (ESL) Programs: Many schools in New York offer ESL programs for newly arrived immigrant students. These programs provide intensive instruction in English language skills, including reading, writing, listening, and speaking.

2. Bilingual Education Programs: Some schools offer transitional bilingual education (TBE) or dual language bilingual education (DLBE) programs for newly arrived immigrant students. These programs provide instruction in both English and the student’s native language to help them maintain their home language while they learn English.

3. Multilingual Learner Support Services: The New York State Education Department provides various support services for multilingual learners, including professional development for teachers, resources for families, and guidance on state policies and regulations.

4. Office of English Language Learners: The New York City Department of Education has an Office of English Language Learners (OELL) that supports schools in serving their diverse population of English language learners through professional development, resources, and policy guidance.

5. Community-based Organizations: There are numerous community-based organizations in New York that provide support to newly arrived immigrant students and their families. These organizations may offer after-school programs, tutoring services, cultural enrichment activities, and other forms of support to help students adapt to their new school environment.

6. Translation and Interpretation Services: Many schools have staff or contract with outside agencies to provide translation and interpretation services for families who speak languages other than English.

7. School-Based ELL Parent Centers: Some schools have dedicated ELL parent centers that provide resources and support specifically for immigrant families, such as workshops on navigating the U.S. education system or connecting families with social services.

8. Peer-to-Peer Mentoring Programs: Some schools have implemented peer-to-peer mentoring programs where established students help newly arrived immigrant students integrate into the school community by providing academic and social support.

9 . Online Resources: There are many online resources available to help newly arrived immigrant students learn English and integrate into the American school system. These include websites, apps, and online courses specifically designed for English language learners.

10. Cultural Awareness Programs: Some schools offer cultural awareness programs to help all students understand and appreciate the diverse backgrounds of their classmates, including newly arrived immigrant students.

11. Family Engagement: Schools in New York strive to engage families of newly arrived immigrant students in their child’s education through regular communication, family workshops, and events that celebrate diversity and promote parental involvement in the school community.

12. Have there been any cases reported of immigrants being unfairly targeted by school resource officers or other forms of security personnel within schools in New York?


Unfortunately, yes. In 2018, there were reports of school resource officers unfairly targeting and harassing immigrant students in New York City public schools. These incidents included detaining and questioning students about their immigration status, making derogatory comments towards immigrant students, and unjustly arresting and transferring them to ICE custody. As a result, the New York Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit against the city’s Department of Education for failing to adequately protect immigrant students from being targeted by school security officers.

13. How do states like California implement inclusive education policies that prioritize school safety for both native-born and immigrant students?


States like California can implement inclusive education policies that prioritize school safety for both native-born and immigrant students by:

1. Promoting diversity and cultural sensitivity: Schools can promote diversity and cultural sensitivity among students through various activities such as celebrating different cultures, incorporating diverse perspectives into the curriculum, and promoting tolerance and understanding.

2. Providing resources for English Language Learners (ELLs): California has a large population of ELLs, so it is important for schools to provide resources to support their language development and academic success. This can include hiring bilingual staff, offering ESL classes, and providing accommodations for ELLs in the classroom.

3. Implementing anti-bullying policies: States like California have laws that specifically address bullying based on race or ethnicity. Schools can create safe and inclusive environments by implementing anti-bullying policies and promoting a zero-tolerance approach to discrimination or harassment.

4. Developing trauma-informed practices: Many immigrant students may have experienced trauma in their home countries or during their journey to the United States. By implementing trauma-informed practices, schools can better support these students by understanding their needs and creating a safe environment that promotes healing.

5. Providing mental health support: Immigrant students may face unique challenges related to immigration status, family separation, or acculturation stress. Schools should provide access to mental health services and resources for students who may be struggling with these issues.

6. Collaborating with community organizations: Working with local community organizations that serve immigrant populations can help schools better understand the needs of their immigrant students and provide resources or referrals when necessary.

7. Ensuring equal access to education: Schools must ensure that all students, regardless of immigration status, have equal access to education opportunities such as extracurricular activities, advanced courses, and college preparation programs.

8. Training staff on diversity and inclusion: Ongoing training for teachers and staff on topics such as cultural competency, equity, and inclusion can help create a safe and supportive learning environment for all students.

9. Addressing immigration-related fears and concerns: With the current political climate, many immigrant students may have fears or concerns about their safety and security. Schools can address these concerns by openly communicating with students and their families, providing accurate information, and connecting them with resources.

10. Involving parents and families in the school community: Schools should make an effort to involve parents and families of immigrant students in the school community. This can help build trust and create a sense of belonging for both the student and their family.

14. How do state-level policies recognize cultural diversity as a means to address potential conflicts among different student groups, including immigrant youth, within qualitative assessments monitored through surveys?


State-level policies recognize cultural diversity as a means to address potential conflicts among different student groups, including immigrant youth, within qualitative assessments monitored through surveys in the following ways:

1. Inclusive curriculum: Many state policies require schools to adopt an inclusive curriculum that represents the diverse cultures and backgrounds of students. This helps create learning environments that promote understanding and respect for different cultures and can reduce conflicts among students.

2. Multicultural education: Some states have specific programs or initiatives dedicated to promoting multicultural education in schools. This type of education emphasizes the importance of diversity and teaches students about different cultures, traditions, and perspectives. By incorporating this into school policies, states encourage schools to create an environment where cultural diversity is valued and celebrated.

3. Cultural sensitivity training: Many states require teachers and staff to undergo cultural sensitivity training as part of their professional development. This helps educators understand and address cultural differences among students, leading to more positive interactions and reduced conflicts.

4. Language access programs: To better support immigrant youth, many states have implemented language access programs that provide translation services for parents and students who are not proficient in English. This can help improve communication between school staff and families, reducing potential conflicts due to language barriers.

5. Student surveys: Some states use student surveys to gather feedback on the school climate and cultural competency of staff. These surveys may include questions specifically related to diversity issues, allowing state officials to monitor the effectiveness of existing policies in addressing potential conflicts among different student groups.

6. Diversity training for school leaders: State policies may also require school leaders, such as principals or superintendents, to participate in diversity training to support their skills in creating an inclusive school environment.

7. Parent involvement: States may also encourage parental involvement through policies that promote a diverse parent-teacher association or multicultural events at schools. By involving parents from different backgrounds, schools can foster a sense of community and understanding among diverse groups.

Overall, state-level policies recognize the importance of cultural diversity in promoting a positive school climate and reducing conflicts among different student groups. By monitoring these policies through surveys, states can assess their effectiveness and make necessary changes to better support a diverse student population.

15.Did recent statewide education budget cuts have an impact on efforts to improve safety for immigrant students in New York schools?


It is likely that the recent statewide education budget cuts in New York have had an impact on efforts to improve safety for immigrant students in schools. These budget cuts have resulted in reductions in funding for school programs and resources, including those aimed at supporting and protecting immigrant students.

For example, many schools have had to cut or reduce counseling services, which can be crucial for providing emotional support and addressing any trauma experienced by immigrant students. Additionally, budget cuts may limit the ability of schools to provide adequate language support and cultural sensitivity training for teachers and staff, which are important factors in creating a safe and inclusive environment for immigrant students.

Moreover, budget cuts may also hinder efforts to implement policies and programs that specifically address the safety concerns of immigrant students, such as anti-bullying initiatives targeting discrimination and racism towards immigrants.

In summary, while there is no direct evidence linking the budget cuts to a decline in safety for immigrant students, it is plausible that these cuts have impacted the ability of schools to create a safe and welcoming environment for these vulnerable populations.

16. In what ways do state policies support school personnel in recognizing and addressing the unique challenges faced by immigrant students, such as language barriers or cultural adjustment?


State policies may support school personnel in recognizing and addressing the unique challenges faced by immigrant students in several ways, including:

1. Funding for English Language Learners (ELLs): Many states provide additional funding for schools with a high number of ELL students, which can be used to hire specialist teachers or provide extra resources such as language instruction materials.

2. Bilingual and Multicultural Programs: Some states require or offer bilingual or multicultural programs that are specifically designed to support the cultural and linguistic needs of immigrant students. These programs may incorporate native language instruction, cultural sensitivity training, and other resources to help students adjust to their new environment.

3. Professional Development: States may require school personnel to participate in professional development opportunities related to teaching ELLs or working with diverse student populations. This can include workshops on language acquisition strategies, cultural competency, and creating an inclusive classroom environment.

4. Assessment and Placement Tools: State policies may mandate the use of assessment tools that are specifically designed for ELLs, which can help school personnel better understand their academic strengths and needs. This information can then inform placement into appropriate classes and support services.

5. Data Collection and Reporting: Many states require schools to collect data on the performance of immigrant students, including graduation rates, academic achievement levels, and English proficiency levels. This data can help school personnel identify trends and areas where improvement is needed.

6. Parent Engagement: State policies may include provisions for engaging immigrant parents in their children’s education by providing translated materials or hiring bilingual staff to communicate with families.

7. Counseling Services: Schools may be required by state policies to provide counseling services or referrals for mental health support for immigrant students who are experiencing emotional or psychological difficulties due to acculturation stress or trauma from their home country experiences.

8. Accommodations for Individual Needs: Depending on state laws, schools may be required or encouraged to make reasonable accommodations for individual needs of immigrant students such as providing interpretation services or allowing for different grading standards for ELLs.

9. Anti-Discrimination Policies: States may enforce laws that prohibit discrimination based on race, ethnicity, or national origin in public schools, ensuring that immigrant students are treated fairly and given equal opportunities to succeed.

10. Legal Protections: State policies may provide legal protections for immigrant students and their families, such as ensuring confidentiality of student records and prohibiting schools from reporting immigration status to federal authorities.

17. Is there a system in place to monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of state policies on school safety for immigrant students in New York?


Yes, the New York State Education Department (NYSED) has a system in place to monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of state policies on school safety for immigrant students. This system includes:

1. Reporting Requirements: All schools in New York are required to report incidents of harassment, discrimination, and bullying to NYSED.

2. Data Collection and Analysis: NYSED collects and analyzes data on school safety, including incidents of harassment, discrimination, and bullying towards immigrant students.

3. School Climate Surveys: NYSED conducts annual school climate surveys to gather feedback from students, parents, and staff regarding their perceptions of safety and inclusivity in schools.

4. Review of Policies: NYSED conducts regular reviews of state policies and regulations related to school safety to ensure they are effective in addressing the needs of immigrant students.

5. Advisory Committees: NYSED has established advisory committees that focus on issues related to immigrant student populations, including the Safe Schools Task Force.

6. Collaboration with Community Organizations: NYSED works closely with community organizations that support immigrant students to gather input and feedback on state policies related to school safety.

7. Evaluation Reports: Periodic evaluation reports are published by NYSED which assess the effectiveness of state policies on school safety for immigrant students.

By continuously monitoring and evaluating state policies on school safety for immigrant students, NYSED can identify areas that need improvement and make necessary changes to better support this vulnerable population.

18. Are there any partnerships between state agencies and community-based organizations to provide resources and support for immigrant students’ safety in schools?


Yes, there are some partnerships between state agencies and community-based organizations to support immigrant students’ safety in schools. For example, the Department of Education may partner with local immigrant organizations to provide cultural competency training for school staff and facilitate dialogue between school officials and immigrant families. Other partnerships may include collaborations between state child welfare agencies and community centers that offer after-school programs for immigrant youth. Additionally, state departments of health may collaborate with community-based health clinics to provide mental health services for immigrant students who have experienced trauma or discrimination in school settings. These partnerships aim to create a supportive environment for immigrant students in schools and ensure their safety and well-being.

19. What role do local authorities play in implementing state policies related to school safety for immigrant students?


Local authorities play a critical role in implementing state policies related to school safety for immigrant students. This includes:

1. Developing protocols and procedures: Local authorities work closely with schools to develop clear protocols and procedures for ensuring the safety of immigrant students. This may include identifying potential risks or threats, establishing emergency response plans, and creating guidelines for supporting immigrant students who may face bullying or discrimination.

2. Providing resources: Local authorities are responsible for providing necessary resources, such as funding, training, and support staff, to help schools implement state policies related to school safety for immigrant students.

3. Promoting awareness and collaboration: Local authorities play a key role in promoting awareness about state policies and laws related to immigration and school safety. They also foster collaboration among schools, community organizations, and law enforcement agencies to address any challenges that may arise.

4. Enforcing compliance: It is the responsibility of local authorities to ensure that schools comply with state policies related to school safety for immigrant students. This includes monitoring implementation, addressing any issues or violations, and reporting back to state officials.

5. Supporting culturally responsive practices: Local authorities can provide guidance and support to teachers on how to create a safe learning environment for immigrant students by incorporating culturally responsive teaching practices that value diversity and promote inclusivity.

6. Addressing language barriers: Local authorities can offer translation services or resources for schools to use in order to effectively communicate important information about school safety policies with non-English speaking immigrant families.

7. Providing legal assistance: In some cases, local authorities may be able to provide legal assistance or referrals for immigrant students who face particular safety concerns related to their immigration status.

Overall, the involvement of local authorities is crucial in ensuring that state policies related to school safety are effectively implemented and tailored to meet the specific needs of immigrant students in their communities.

20. How do state-level policies uphold the rights of immigrant students to access education without fear of discrimination or retaliation in New York schools?


1. Protection against Immigration Status Inquiries: New York state law prohibits school officials from asking students or their families about their immigration status in order to prevent discrimination and ensure equal access to education.

2. Non-Discrimination Policies: New York state has a strong non-discrimination policy in place that protects all students, regardless of their immigration status, from discrimination based on race, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, etc.

3. Language Access: The state requires schools to provide language assistance to English language learners and their families in order to ensure they have access to the same educational opportunities as other students.

4. Special Education Services: Immigrant students with disabilities are entitled to receive special education services like any other student under federal law (IDEA). New York also has additional policies in place to address the unique needs of immigrant students with disabilities.

5. Enrollment Rights: All schools in New York are required by law to enroll every eligible student in school regardless of their immigration status or documentation. This includes undocumented students who have the right to attend public schools without paying higher tuition fees.

6. Protection Against Harassment/Bullying: The Dignity for All Students Act (DASA) prohibits harassment and bullying based on a student’s actual or perceived immigration status. Schools are required to establish protocols for addressing incidents of harassment and bullying and take appropriate disciplinary action when necessary.

7. Provision of Supportive Services: Schools in New York are encouraged to provide supportive services such as counseling or mental health resources for immigrant students facing challenges related to their immigration status or experiences.

8. Training for Educators: The state provides training and resources for educators on how best to support immigrant students and create welcoming environments that promote diversity and inclusivity.

9. Confidentiality Protections: Federal laws like FERPA and IDEA protect the privacy of all students’ records, including those of undocumented immigrants, ensuring that sensitive information is not shared without consent.

10. Sanctuary Policies: Some localities within New York state, such as New York City, have enacted sanctuary policies that limit cooperation with federal immigration authorities and protect the rights of immigrants in school settings.