Language Access and Information on Internet Services in California

1. What measures does California have in place to ensure language access for limited English proficient individuals in accessing internet services?


California has several measures in place to ensure language access for limited English proficient individuals in accessing internet services:

1. Multilingual Websites: Many government websites in California offer content in multiple languages, including Spanish, Chinese and Vietnamese.

2. Translation Services: The state offers translation services for various digital resources such as website content, legal documents and online forms. This ensures that limited English proficient individuals have access to important information and services.

3. Language Assistance Programs: California provides language assistance programs, such as the Languages Services program, which offers interpretation services for telephone calls to state agencies and departments.

4. Language Access Plan: The state has a Language Access Implementation Plan (LAIP) in place to ensure that state agencies and departments are complying with language access laws and providing meaningful access to LEP individuals.

5. Language Access Coordinators: Each state agency must designate a language access coordinator who is responsible for overseeing compliance with language access laws and policies.

6. Training: California offers training programs to help state employees understand their responsibilities under language access laws and policies.

7. Bilingual Services at Public Libraries: Many public libraries in California offer bilingual staff and resources, including computer stations with multilingual capabilities, making it easier for LEP individuals to access internet services.

8. Partnership with Community Organizations: The state works closely with community organizations that serve LEP populations to identify specific needs and improve outreach efforts.

9. Complaint Process: California has a complaint process in place for individuals who have experienced barriers or difficulties accessing internet services due to limited English proficiency. This allows the state to address any issues that may arise and improve language access moving forward.

10 . Executive Order N-15-19: In 2019, Governor Gavin Newsom signed an executive order mandating new standards for linguistic accessibility across all state agencies’ communications with LEP communities, including digital communications such as websites, applications, social media posts, videos, and more. This executive order aims to improve language access for LEP individuals in all aspects of government services, including internet services.

2. Are all state government websites in California available in multiple languages?

No, not all state government websites in California are available in multiple languages. While many government websites offer information and resources in languages other than English, it is not a requirement for all websites to have a multilingual option. The specific languages offered may also vary depending on the agency or department running the website.

3. How does California make information on internet services accessible to individuals with disabilities?


California has several laws and guidelines in place to ensure that information on internet services is accessible to individuals with disabilities. These include:

1. Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): Under this federal law, businesses and organizations in California are required to make their websites accessible to people with disabilities, including those who are blind or visually impaired.

2. Unruh Civil Rights Act: This state law prohibits discrimination against individuals on the basis of disability, including in the digital realm. It requires all businesses in California, whether online or brick-and-mortar, to provide equal access to goods and services for individuals with disabilities.

3. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG): The state has adopted WCAG 2.0 as the technical standard for website accessibility. This means that all California state agencies must comply with these guidelines and ensure that their websites are easily navigable by people with disabilities.

4. Section 508 Standards: These standards establish technical requirements for federal agencies’ electronic and information technology accessibility under the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. They outline specific requirements for how web content should be designed and structured to be accessible to people with disabilities.

5. Assistive Technology: The state also offers assistive technology programs to help people with disabilities access information on the internet. This includes resources such as specialized software, computer hardware, video conferencing equipment, screen readers and magnifiers, speech recognition software, and alternative input devices.

6. Accessible Phones: All telecommunications companies operating in California are required by law to offer accessible telephone services for customers with hearing or speech impairments.

7.Compensation: Individuals who encounter barriers when accessing information on internet services due to a disability may file a complaint under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or seek compensation through the courts under the Unruh Civil Rights Act.

These laws and guidelines ensure that information on internet services is accessible to individuals with disabilities in California and promote inclusivity and equal access for all individuals.

4. Is there a requirement for private companies providing internet services in California to offer translation and interpretation options for non-English speakers?


No, there is currently no specific requirement for private companies providing internet services in California to offer translation and interpretation options for non-English speakers. However, under the federal law Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, private companies that receive funding from the government are required to provide language assistance services to limited English proficient individuals. Additionally, the California state government has made efforts to encourage businesses to provide translated materials and services through its Language Access Compliance Program. Private internet service providers may choose to offer translation and interpretation options as a way to comply with these regulations or as a customer service strategy.

5. How does California address the digital divide for underserved communities, including those with limited English proficiency?


1. Digital Literacy Programs: The state of California has several digital literacy programs aimed at helping underserved communities gain access to technology and become proficient in using digital tools. Some examples include the California Teleconnect Fund, which provides discounted telecommunications services to qualifying schools, libraries, and community organizations; the Get Connected! Program which offers free technology training classes for low-income residents; and the statewide Digital Inclusion Resource Guide, which connects individuals with computer training resources in their local area.

2. Broadband Infrastructure Funding: California has also invested significant funds into expanding broadband infrastructure and improving internet access in rural and low-income areas. For example, the California Advanced Services Fund (CASF) provides grants to Internet Service Providers (ISPs) for broadband infrastructure projects in unserved or underserved areas.

3. Multilingual Resources: In order to address language barriers for those with limited English proficiency, California has made efforts to provide digital resources in multiple languages. For instance, the state government websites are available in various languages such as Spanish, Chinese, Vietnamese, Korean, Tagalog and Arabic.

4. Community Partnerships: Several public-private partnerships have been established in California to promote digital inclusion among underserved communities. These partnerships work with local organizations to provide technology training and resources to residents who may not have access otherwise.

5. Digital Navigators: Many communities within California have implemented digital navigator programs where individuals who are well-versed in technology help bridge the gap between underserved communities and technology by providing support and guidance on how to use digital tools effectively.

6. Internet Subsidies: The state has also taken steps towards reducing financial barriers by offering subsidies for internet service through CalFresh EBT cards (previously known as food stamps), making it easier for low-income families to access high-speed internet from home.

7. Educational Initiatives: The California Department of Education has leveraged its statewide education initiatives like Equity Labs – a program geared towards promoting digital equity to enable underserved public school students to learn and use technology in innovative ways. Technical assistance is also provided for schools to promote greater parental engagement through technology.

6. What resources are available in California for non-English speakers to learn about using internet services (e.g. online tutorials, multilingual hotlines)?

There are several resources available in California for non-English speakers to learn about using internet services, including:

1. California State Library: The California State Library offers a variety of online resources and tutorials in multiple languages on topics such as computer skills, internet basics, and online safety.

2. Public Libraries: Many public libraries across California offer free computer and internet access, as well as classes and workshops on using internet services. Some may also have staff members who speak languages other than English to assist non-English speakers.

3. Community Colleges: Community colleges often offer low-cost or free computer and technology classes in multiple languages for community members.

4. Nonprofit organizations: There are many nonprofit organizations in California that provide digital literacy classes and workshops for non-English speakers, such as the International Institute of Los Angeles and Upwardly Global.

5. Internet Service Provider (ISP) hotlines: Most major ISPs have customer service hotlines with multilingual support options for their customers. Customers can call these numbers to get assistance with setting up or troubleshooting their internet services.

6. Apps and online tutorials: There are a variety of apps and online tutorials available in different languages that can help non-English speakers learn how to use internet services at their own pace. Some popular apps include Duolingo, Babbel, and Rosetta Stone.

7. Ethnic media outlets: Many ethnic media outlets in California, such as newspapers, radio stations, and websites, offer information about using internet services specifically targeted towards non-English speaking communities.

8. Local community centers: Local community centers often offer computer classes and workshops for residents, which can be a great resource for non-English speakers looking to learn about using internet services.

9. Online forums and social media groups: Non-English speakers can also join online forums or social media groups focused on technology or digital literacy to connect with others who speak their language and ask questions or share knowledge.

10. Local businesses and community organizations: Local businesses and community organizations, such as churches or civic groups, may also offer workshops or classes on using internet services for non-English speakers in their communities.

7. Does the state provide funding or support for community-based organizations to promote language access and information on internet services among minority populations?


It is unclear if the state specifically provides funding or support for community-based organizations to promote language access and information on internet services among minority populations. However, many states have initiatives or programs aimed at promoting digital literacy and increasing access to broadband and other online resources for disadvantaged and minority communities. These initiatives may involve partnerships with community-based organizations to help reach underserved populations. Examples include the California Advanced Services Fund, which supports projects that provide broadband access in unserved or underserved areas of the state, and the New York State Broadband Program Office, which works with community organizations to identify areas where broadband is needed and develop plans for deployment. Additionally, some states have established statewide networks of public libraries that work closely with local community groups to provide resources and workshops on digital literacy skills.

8. Are there any initiatives or campaigns in California aimed at increasing awareness of language access and navigating the internet among immigrant communities?


Yes, there are several initiatives and campaigns in California aimed at increasing awareness of language access and navigating the internet among immigrant communities. Some examples include:

1. The California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation (CRLAF) launched a campaign called “Digital Connectors” in rural communities to empower low-income immigrants with digital literacy skills and provide language support for navigating the internet.

2. The Immigrant Legal Resource Center (ILRC) has developed a series of online training courses, webinars, and resources in different languages to educate immigrant communities on their rights and how to access legal information online.

3. The California Immigrant Policy Center (CIPC) has a Language Access Program that supports community organizations in providing language assistance for limited-English proficient immigrants, including translating materials and conducting outreach efforts.

4. The California Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development launched the “GoBiz website” which provides information on how to start or grow a business in multiple languages, including Spanish, Chinese, Korean, Vietnamese, and Tagalog.

5. Mission Asset Fund created the Lending Circles for Individuals initiative which is a peer-to-peer microlending program that provides financial education and resources to predominantly immigrant communities through their online platform.

6. Non-profit organization Upwardly Global offers free online job search training programs in multiple languages to help immigrant professionals navigate the US job market.

7. The Golden State Opportunity Foundation runs an education campaign called “CalEITC4Me” which promotes awareness of the state’s earned income tax credit among low-income immigrants who may not have access to information about this benefit.

8. The City of San Francisco offers free technology training courses through its Digital Equity Program for low-income residents including immigrants who may lack basic computer skills or face language barriers in using technology.

9. Are there specific accommodations made for indigenous languages spoken within California on state government websites and other online platforms?


Yes, the California State Government has made accommodations for indigenous languages spoken within the state on its websites and online platforms. These accommodations include providing information and resources in multiple languages, including indigenous languages such as Navajo (Diné), Yurok, and Muskogee (Creek). Additionally, the State of California provides translation services for government websites through the Office of Planning and Research Translation Section, which offers translation services in over 30 languages, including many indigenous languages. This ensures that important government information is accessible to all residents of California, regardless of their primary language. The state also has a Native American Languages Program that works to revitalize and preserve indigenous languages by offering grants and resources to support language preservation efforts.

10. How is the effectiveness of language access and information on internet services measured and evaluated by the state government in California?


The effectiveness of language access and information on internet services is closely monitored and evaluated by the state government in California through various mechanisms, including:

1. Surveys and Feedback: The state government routinely conducts surveys among non-English speaking communities to gauge their satisfaction with language access and information on internet services. This helps identify any gaps or areas for improvement.

2. Usage Data: Government agencies track usage data for language-specific webpages and online resources to measure the demand for different languages. They also analyze user behavior to understand which languages are being used more frequently and for what purposes.

3. Compliance Audits: The state government conducts compliance audits to ensure that all state websites are providing necessary language access services as per the requirements of the law.

4. Quality Assurance: Agencies responsible for providing language access services often have quality assurance programs in place that evaluate the accuracy, completeness, and clarity of information provided in different languages.

5. Stakeholder Meetings: Government officials regularly meet with community organizations, advocacy groups, and other stakeholders to discuss issues related to language access and gather feedback on improving services.

6. Language Access Plans: State agencies are required to develop and implement language access plans that outline strategies for improving language services on their websites. These plans serve as a useful tool for monitoring progress towards meeting language access goals.

7.Social Media Engagement: The state government actively engages with non-English speaking communities through social media platforms to promote awareness of available language services and collect feedback on their effectiveness.

8. Training Programs: Government employees responsible for providing language access services undergo regular training programs to ensure they have the necessary skills and knowledge to effectively communicate with non-English speakers using online channels.

9. Complaint Management System: The state government has a system in place where users can file complaints about inadequate or ineffective language support on government websites, which helps identify ongoing issues that need to be addressed.

10. Review by Language Access Coordinators: Each state agency has a designated language access coordinator who is responsible for overseeing the provision of language services on their website. They regularly review and evaluate the effectiveness of language access and information on internet services within their respective agencies.

11. Are public libraries in California equipped with technology tools and resources to assist non-English speakers in accessing internet services?


The level of technology tools and resources available at public libraries in California may vary depending on the specific library. However, many public libraries in California do offer resources and services specifically for non-English speakers, including:

1. Multilingual staff and volunteers who can assist with technology access and questions.

2. Computers with multilingual keyboards and/or software programs that can translate web pages into different languages.

3. Wi-Fi connections that non-English speakers can use with their own devices.

4. Language learning software, such as Rosetta Stone or Mango Languages, that patrons can use to improve their English skills.

5. Translation services for library materials, including books and online resources.

6. Programs, workshops, and classes designed to teach non-English speakers how to use technology effectively.

7. In-person interpretation services or telephone language lines for patrons who need assistance with computer use or other technology-related tasks.

8. Access to digital resources such as e-books, audiobooks, and online databases in multiple languages.

9. Partnering with community organizations or local schools to provide technology training and support for non-English speaking individuals.

10. Providing culturally relevant resources and educational materials in multiple languages to promote digital literacy among non-English speakers.

Overall, while the specific tools and resources may vary by library, many public libraries in California strive to provide inclusive and equitable access to technology for all members of their community, including non-English speakers.

12. What steps are being taken by the state government to improve language access and information on internet services for refugees and other displaced populations residing in California?


The state government of California has taken several steps to improve language access and information on internet services for refugees and other displaced populations. These include:

1. Offering translation services for government websites: The California Department of Technology provides a translation service that enables refugees and other non-English speaking persons to access information and services provided by state agencies.

2. Providing multilingual resources on state websites: Many state government websites, including the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development, offer multilingual resources in languages such as Spanish, Chinese and Vietnamese.

3. Partnering with community-based organizations: The California Department of Community Services and Development works closely with community-based organizations to provide training, technical assistance, and other support for improving language access for refugees and other displaced populations.

4. Funding language access initiatives: The state government provides funding to local agencies and organizations to ensure that refugee communities have access to essential information in their own language.

5. Supporting multilingual education programs: To address the educational needs of refugee children, the California Department of Education supports bilingual education programs in schools that serve high numbers of refugee students.

6. Providing interpretation services in public facilities: Many public facilities such as hospitals, libraries, and welfare offices offer interpretation services in multiple languages to assist refugees and other limited English proficiency individuals.

7. Investing in digital literacy programs: The California State Library offers digital literacy programs for immigrant populations to help them develop basic computer skills needed to navigate online resources.

8. Reaching out through social media: Government agencies use social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter, Instagram etc., to reach out to diverse communities with information about available services in multiple languages.

9. Creating culturally sensitive materials: Agencies work with translation providers who understand different cultures to produce translations that are appropriate for use within different communities.

10. Conducting outreach events in different languages: State agencies hold community outreach events where they provide information on essential services available in various foreign languages spoken by refugee and other displaced populations.

11. Providing training to state and local employees: The California Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) provides language access training to all staff members that conduct outreach to the community, engage in public speaking, or represent DIR at meetings or events.

12. Implementing language access plans: To ensure that refugees and other displaced populations have meaningful access to services, state agencies are required to have a Language Assistance Implementation Plan in place. This serves as a guideline for providing language assistance services for individuals with limited English proficiency.

13. Do state agencies or departments have designated multilingual staff responsible for ensuring language accessibility on their websites and online platforms?


It is likely that many state agencies and departments have designated multilingual staff responsible for ensuring language accessibility on their websites and online platforms. This can vary depending on the specific agency or department, as well as the resources and priorities of the state. It is important for state governments to prioritize and allocate resources to ensure their websites and online platforms are accessible to all individuals, regardless of language barriers.

14. Is there a hotline or helpline specifically dedicated to addressing language barriers faced by individuals seeking assistance with internet services within California?


Yes, the California Public Utilities Commission has a Consumer Affairs Branch that operates a hotline specifically dedicated to addressing language barriers and other issues related to internet services. The hotline can be reached at 1-800-649-7570.

15. How is confidentiality maintained when providing translation or interpretation assistance for individuals accessing online government services in California?


Confidentiality is maintained by adhering to the laws and guidelines set forth by the California government, as well as any established policies and procedures of the translation or interpretation service provider. This may include obtaining signed consent forms, utilizing secure communication channels, and restricting access to personal information to only those who need it for the translation or interpretation process. Additionally, translators and interpreters are bound by professional standards of ethics that require them to maintain confidentiality at all times.

16. Are online forms and applications for state services available in languages other than English in California?


Yes, online forms and applications for state services are available in languages other than English in California. As a diverse and multicultural state, California recognizes the importance of providing access to government services for individuals who speak languages other than English. Many state agencies offer their forms and applications in multiple languages, including Spanish, Chinese, Vietnamese, and Korean. Some agencies also have interpreters available to assist with completing forms and applications over the phone or in person. Additionally, the state’s official website provides translation options for its content in multiple languages through the “Translate” feature at the top of the page.

17. Is there a central database or directory of state-approved translation services for individuals seeking language assistance with internet services?

I am not aware of a central database or directory specifically for state-approved translation services for internet services. However, you may find some state-specific directories or databases through individual state government websites or organizations such as the National Association of Judiciary Interpreters and Translators (NAJIT). Additionally, many federal agencies have lists of approved translation vendors for their specific language needs.

18. Are materials on cyber security and safe internet practices available in various languages for non-English speakers in California?


Yes, materials on cyber security and safe internet practices are available in various languages for non-English speakers in California. These materials can be found through government agencies, nonprofits, and online resources. Some examples include:

1. The California Department of Technology offers resources on cybersecurity in multiple languages including Spanish, Chinese, Vietnamese, Filipino/Tagalog, and Korean.
2. The California Cybersecurity Integration Center has information available in 10 languages including Arabic, Hindi, and Farsi.
3. The California Office of the Attorney General has a comprehensive guide on internet safety available in Spanish and Tagalog.
4. Nonprofit organizations such as the Center for Cyber Safety and Education provide multilingual resources for parents on how to keep their children safe online.
5. Online resources like StaySafeOnline.org have educational materials available in several languages including Spanish, French, and Hindi.

It is important to note that these are just a few examples of available resources; there may be many more available through local community organizations or libraries. Additionally, it may be helpful to check with your local government or school district for resources specifically tailored for your community’s needs.

19. How does California ensure that its websites and online platforms comply with federal laws such as Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act, which mandates accessibility for individuals with disabilities?


California has implemented several measures to ensure compliance with federal laws, such as Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act, which mandates accessibility for individuals with disabilities. These include:

1. Procurement Guidelines: California has established specific procurement guidelines that require state agencies and departments to purchase technology that meets federal accessibility standards.

2. Training: State employees involved in website or online platform development are required to complete training on accessibility standards and requirements.

3. Compliance Reviews: The California Department of Technology conducts regular compliance reviews of state websites and online platforms to identify any potential accessibility issues and ensure they are addressed.

4. Technical Assistance: State agencies can seek technical assistance from the California Department of Technology’s Digital Services Division, which provides guidance on how to make websites and online platforms accessible.

5. Accessibility Standards: California has adopted the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.0 Level AA as the standard for web accessibility, which aligns with federal requirements under Section 508.

6. Complaint Process: Individuals can file a complaint if they encounter barriers while accessing a state website or online platform due to a disability. The California Department of Technology will investigate the complaint and work with the agency responsible for the website/platform to address any accessibility issues.

7. Voluntary Compliance Program: The state also offers a voluntary compliance program that allows entities subject to Section 508 to self-regulate their compliance efforts through regular self-assessments and reporting.

8. Partnerships: The California Department of Technology works closely with organizations representing individuals with disabilities and other stakeholders to improve and maintain the accessibility of state websites and online platforms.

20. Are there any upcoming initiatives or plans to further improve language access and information on internet services within California?


The California Department of Technology has launched the Language Access Strategic Plan in 2020 with an aim to improve language access and information on internet services within California. The plan includes initiatives such as:

1. Expanding multilingual resources on government websites: The state is working on providing translated content in multiple languages on government websites to make information more accessible for non-English speakers.

2. Implementing machine translation tools: The state has begun using machine translation tools to automatically translate website content into different languages, reducing the time and cost of human translation.

3. Developing a centralized online portal for language resources: The state is creating an online portal that will serve as a one-stop-shop for all language resources and services provided by the government.

4. Providing interpreter services: The state is exploring ways to provide interpreter services on government websites through video or telephone conferencing for real-time language support.

5. Creating training programs for government employees: The state is developing training programs for government employees to improve their cultural competency and communication skills when interacting with non-English speaking individuals.

6. Conducting outreach to diverse communities: The state is partnering with community organizations to conduct outreach and raise awareness about the availability of language access services in various languages.

7. Collaborating with technology companies: The state is collaborating with technology companies to develop innovative solutions that can improve language access on digital platforms.

8. Engaging with stakeholders: The Language Access Task Force, established by the Language Access Strategic Plan, regularly engages with stakeholders from diverse communities to identify their needs and concerns related to language accessibility on digital platforms.

Overall, these initiatives are aimed at improving access to vital information and services for people from diverse linguistic backgrounds in California.